Image credit: حُميد, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
In 2024, Manish arrived as a general labourer at Saad 2 Solar PV Plant, a flagship solar project in Riyadh. Employment in Saudi Arabia’s rapidly expanding renewables sector would provide greater financial security for his wife, daughter and elderly parents back home in Nepal. After successive droughts and heavy rainfall reduced agricultural yields on their land, this was an opportunity for a better future.
The reality was very different. Manish was charged USD 1,350 in recruitment fees by his recruiter, a violation of both international standards - Opens in new tab and local law - Opens in new tab. He earned just USD 295 per month and was subjected to a litany of harsh working conditions.
“The company exploited us terribly,” Manish said when he finally returned home. “We were treated like hens, only valued for the eggs we lay.”
Manish has received neither an apology nor compensation for the abuses he suffered.
And his experience is not unique.
Forced labour and barriers to justice
This year, the Business and Human Rights Centre found - Opens in new tab that Nepali and Bangladeshi workers powering the energy transition in Saudi Arabia remain without remedy, eight months after we first told companies - Opens in new tab of the egregious abuse they had suffered.
Workers on nine solar and green hydrogen projects had described - Opens in new tab endemic abuse, including charging of recruitment fees, safety violations, and severe reprisals for raising complaints. Over half of the 34 interviewed were subjected to five or more indicators of forced labour - Opens in new tab.
The ongoing lack of redress exposes a profound failure by major multinational renewable energy developers and financiers to uphold the responsibility to respect human rights. It also highlights a disconnect between the rhetoric of a sustainable transition and the lived realities of the migrant workers driving it.
Saad 2 cost around USD 829 million to develop, with USD 220 million invested by the project’s developers and USD 609 million loaned by international banks. Manish worked for a subcontractor of POWERCHINA, a global engineering giant - Opens in new tab ranking in the top fifth - Opens in new tab of the Fortune Global 500.
He walked six kilometres every day while hauling cables under the relentless sun. The heat was so intense that several colleagues collapsed around him. “My shoes would get soaked with sweat from the heat," Manish recalled. "It was unbearably hot.”
The searing temperatures were only part of the ordeal. Manish described a workplace governed by intimidation, coercion and violence. Supervisors beat workers with helmets, kicked them, and drove them to work faster.
With no effective grievance mechanism, workers had little hope that their concerns would be heard. “The company said we could leave work if we were not happy,” Manish explained. “Since there was no sign of addressing [our concerns], who would risk their jobs?”
Workers who were desperate to resign before the end of their contracts were required to pay the company at least USD 750, equivalent to nearly three months' wages.
Manish was then abruptly dismissed without explanation.
“I asked the company to give me tanajul [sponsorship transfer] so that I could go for another employer. But the company denied [it to me],” Manish said. “I had my passport with me, but how could I come [home] without the company's permission?”
“I’ll not go to Saudi again. There were many workers who were crying inside but felt compelled to work due to financial hardships and debt. Nobody wants to work for that company. It doesn’t treat workers like humans,” Manish said.
Who is responsible for remedy?
Remedy is a cornerstone of international human rights law - Opens in new tab. The obligations of businesses are clarified through international - Opens in new tab frameworks - Opens in new tab, which state that the responsibility for remedy is shared across the supply chain.
Companies that directly cause harm, like Manish’s employer, must provide remedy. When there are multiple stakeholders involved, companies whose actions contribute to abuse through their contracting and purchasing practices should also provide remedy or cooperate in the process. For Manish, this may include POWERCHINA and the project developers: workers on Saad 2 told BHRC how their working conditions worsened when POWERCHINA imposed financial penalties on subcontractors and terminated contracts.
If I make a mistake, [POWERCHINA] fines our supply company, which in
turn may cause trouble for me… If the supply company is fined due to our
mistakes, they deduct the penalty from our salaries.
Nepali logistics worker on Saad 2 Solar PV Project
The responsibility to act also extends to - Opens in new tabbanks who may be directly linked to the abuse by funding the projects. Lenders should use their leverage to ensure their clients participate in any remedy process, including by raising workers’ testimonies with clients’ leadership and making further financing conditional on the provision of timely remedy.
The ongoing failure to provide remedy is a grave breach of international standards. Companies connected to the abuse must urgently engage with affected workers through meaningful, trauma-informed dialogue to understand what they need and expect.
What remedy means to workers
When we asked workers what remedy they wanted, their demands were clear: repayment of recruitment fees and withheld wages; fair salaries that enable them to break free from cycles of debt and poverty; and meaningful reforms to ensure others are not subjected to similar harm.
“They should provide enough rest at work, proper safety equipment, clean accommodation and fair salaries,” said Manish. “I also want a refund of the money I spent on recruitment fees and interest.”
For workers like Manish, remedy would provide relief not just for themselves, but for their families, who have also borne the consequences of exploitation. “My mother is sick. I could buy medicine with that money,” Manish explained. “And my daughter is growing up. She goes to school, but I don’t have enough money to support her. If I receive a refund, it would make a huge difference to my family.”
For the workers we spoke to, remedy is about restoring dignity and security and ensuring other workers do not suffer the same abuse. Until that happens, the profits of Saudi’s energy transition continue to come at too high a cost for migrant workers.
This article draws on findings from Business and Human Rights Centre’s report, “It would change my life”: Remedy, reparations and justice for migrant workers in Saudi Arabia’s renewable energy industry - Opens in new tab. Manish’s name has been changed to protect his identity. Investment information was provided by BankTrack.
All companies connected to the abuse were invited by BHRC to respond to our findings in both 2025 - Opens in new tab and 2026 - Opens in new tab. Of companies named in this article, responses were received from HSBC (2025 - Opens in new tab; 2026 - Opens in new tab) and Mizuho Financial Group (2025 - Opens in new tab; 2026 - Opens in new tab). POWERCHINA, ACWA Power and the PIF are yet to respond.

